Debating+Archive


 * Feedback **
 * At senior level feedback should be very limited. These are experienced debaters who do not need the adjudicator’s opinion. Telling students to slow down so the adjudicator can keep up with the argument only exposes the adjudicator to ridicule.
 * At junior level some feedback might be valuable, but only if the comments refer to where marks were gained and lost.
 * Feedback should be given to both teams and the audience rather than privately.

RESULTS ROUND ONE AND TWO **__2014 Year 11 Debating Rounds 1 and 2__** __Round 1, Prepared. Moot: This house would remove the GST on fresh fruits and vegetables before adding a sugar/fat tax.__ ROund 2, Limited Prep. Moot: This house would arm the NZ police
 * __ Year 11 Debating Teams 2014 organised by Nicola Littley __ NLittley@hastingsboys.school.nz **
 * ** School ** || ** Teams ** || ** Coach ** ||
 * Napier Boys || 1 || Catherine Brady CBrady@nbhs.school,nz ||
 * Napier Girls || 1 || Mary-Anne Blair mablair@nghs.school.nz ||
 * Sacred Heart || 1 || James Wakefield JWakefield@sacredheartnapier.school.nz ||
 * Taradale || 1 || Angela Gibbs gi@ths.school.nz ||
 * Karamu || 2 || Amy Price aprice@karamu.school.nz ||
 * St Johns ||  ||   ||
 * Lindisfarne || 1 || Kristy Biggs biggs.kristy@lindisfarnehbschool@onmicrosoft.com ||
 * Hastings Girls || 2 || Mandy Jarden jr@hastingsgirls.com ||
 * Hastings Boys ||  ||   ||
 * Havelock North || 1 || Chris Thomas ts@hnhs.school.nz ||
 * Iona || 1 || Lisa Jane Easter es@iona.school.nz ||
 * Woodford || 1 || Rachel Roberts rachel.roberts@woodford.school.nz ||
 * Central HB || 1 || Juliette Lewis julietteh@chbc.school.nz ||
 * ** TOTAL no. TEAMS ** || 13 ||  ||   ||
 * **Affirmative** || **Negating** ||
 * NGHS 240 || NBHS 256 WINNER ||
 * SHC 249 WINNER || Iona 243 ||
 * Karamu 1 240 WINNER || HGHS 1 224 ||
 * HNHS 225 WINNER || HGHS 2 192 ||
 * Karamu 2 230 WINNER || SJC 1 214 ||
 * Woodford 264 WINNER || SJC 2 247 ||
 * **Affirmative** || **Negating** ||
 * Iona 256 WINNER || NGHS 255 ||
 * NBHS 238 || SHC 241.5 WINNER ||
 * HGHS 1 234 || Lindisfarne 258 WINNER ||
 * HGHS 2 249 WINNER || Karamu 2 218 ||
 * SJC 1 217 || Woodford 233 WINNER ||
 * SJC 2 228 || Karamu 1 280 WINNER ||
 * Taradale 247 WINNER || HNHS 235 ||

Taradale and Lindisfarne only took part in the Limited Prep. CHBC pulled out of this round.

ROUNDS THREE AND FOUR //(HNHS and SHC each had a bye. HNHS was only be involved in the Prepared, SHC in the Limited Prep)//

__Round 3, Prepared. Moot: This house would vote National over Labour in the 2014 election.__
 * **Affirmative** || **Negating** ||
 * NGHS 240 || NBHS 256 WINNER ||
 * SHC 249 WINNER || Iona 243 ||
 * Karamu 1 240 WINNER || HGHS 1 224 ||
 * HNHS 225 WINNER || HGHS 2 192 ||
 * Karamu 2 230 WINNER || SJC 1 214 ||
 * Woodford 264 WINNER || SJC 2 247 ||

__Round 4, Limited Prep. Moot: This house would arm teachers in the USA.__

__Round 5, Limited Prep. Moot: Host's choice__
 * **Affirmative** || **Negating** ||
 * Karamu 1 236 || Taradale 242 WINNER ||
 * Karamu 2 261 WINNER || NBHS 235 ||
 * NGHS 220 WINNER || CHBC 137 ||
 * Woodford 264 WINNER || HGHS 2 250 ||
 * SHC 254.5 WINNER || HGHS 1 249 ||
 * Lindisfarne 259 WINNER || Iona 253.5 ||

//NBHS - BYE//

Semi Finals: Prepared - This House supports drilling in NZ waters FINAL: Limited Prep - That advertising during kid's television shows should be banned
 * **AFFIRMATIVE** || **NEGATIVE** ||
 * Taradale 248 WINNER || Iona 250 WINNER ||
 * CHBC 112 || HNHS 242 ||
 * HGHS 1 276 WINNER || NGHS 273 ||
 * Lindisfarne 266 || SHC 270 WINNER ||
 * Karamu 1 179 || HGHS 2 185 WINNER ||
 * Karamu 2 240 WINNER || Woodford 236 ||
 * **AFFIRMATIVE** || NEGATIVE ||  ||
 * Woodford 277 WINNER || Taradale 27 ||  ||
 * SHC 269 || Karamu 2 271 WINNER ||

__**OVERALL WINNER IN 2014 IS KARAMU 2.**__
 * **AFFIRMATIVE** || NEGATIVE ||  ||
 * Woodford 279 || Karamu 2 294 WINNER ||  ||

2014 Senior Debating Teams in Hawke’s Bay. To make it easier to coordinate school teams are numbered and the main contact is named. Could these schools’ debating coordinators forward information to the other coaches in their schools please?Thanks Lyndie Balfour.
 * __ 2014 Year 12 and 13 Debating Competition __**

CHBC 1, 2 contact by Judith Finlay judithf@chbc.school.nz HBHS 1 contact Nicola Littley at NicolaL@hastingsboys.school.nz HGHS 1, 2 & 3 contact Mandy Jarden jr@hastingsgirls.com HNHS 1 & 2 contact John Bird bd@hnhs.school.nz Iona 2 contact Lisa-Jane Easter es@iona.school.nz KHS 1, 2, 3 Amy Price aprice@karamu.school.nz LC 1, 2, 3, contact Fraser Harrison. harrison.fraser@lindisfarne.hb.school.nz NBHS 1, 2, 3 contact Sarah Robertson srobertson@nbhs.school.nz NGHS 1 & 2 contact Zanita Thompson zthompson@nghs.school.nz SHC 1 contact James Wakefield jwakefield@sacredheartnapier.school.nz SJC 1, 2 & 3 Lyndie Balfour lbalfour@stjohns.school.nz THS 1, 2 contact Robyn Elston r.elston@ths.school.nz Woodford 1 contact Rachel Roberts Rachel.roberts@woodford.school.nz

Limited Prep Moot was 'that we should change the N.Z. flag' CHBC did not arrive so the draw was changed.
 * Round 1 The moot is a judgement moot**
 * __‘This house supports building the Ruataniwha Dam__**
 * Pool A** Hosted by Lindisfarne College-Fraser Harrison in Week 6
 * __Round 1 Prepared__ __Round 2 Limited Prep__**
 * Affirmative Negative Affirmative Negative**
 * HGHS 1 || **LC1 won** || **LC 1 won** || WH1 ||
 * CHBC 2 || **HGHS 2 won** || **HGHS 2 won** || HNHS 1 ||
 * HNHS 1 || **HGHS 3 won** || **HGHS 3 won** || LC 3 ||
 * LC 3 || **HNHS 2 won** || HNHS 2 || **HGHS 1 won** ||
 * **LC 2 won** || by def CHBC ||  ||   ||
 * WH 1 || **HBHS 1 won** || **HBHS 1 won** || LC2 ||

Pool B Hosted by SJC-Lyndie Balfour on Tuesday 18th March 2014 '**__Round 1 Prepared__ __Round 2 Limited Prep__** The limited prep moot was 'that this house should ban zoos.'
 * Affirmative Negative Affirmative Negative**
 * SJC 1 || **IONA 1 won** || IONA 1 || **IONA 2won** ||
 * SJC 2 || **KHS 1 won** || KHS 1 || **SJC 1 won** ||
 * SJC 3 || **KHS 2 won** || **KHS 2 won** || SJC 2 ||
 * **IONA 2 won** || KHS 3 || **KHS 3 won** || SJC 3 ||

Pool C Hosted by NGHS in Week 7-Zanita Thompson The Limited Prep Moot used was 'That school balls are an outdated tradition." __**Round 1 Prepared**__ __**Round 2 Limited Prep**__

Affirmative Negative Affirmative Negative

 * THS 1 || **NBHS 1 won** || **NBHS 1 won** || THS 2 ||
 * NBHS 2 || **NGHS 1 won** || **NGHS 1 won** || THS 1 ||
 * **NGHS 2 won** || NBHS 3 || NBHS 3 || **NBHS 2 won** ||
 * THS 2 Def. || **SHC 1 won by def** || SHC 1 || **NGHS 2 won** ||

**The prepared moot is 'that politics is an admirable profession'**
Pool A Hosted by NBHS Round 3 **Prepared Debate...**Round 4 **Limited Prep**
 * **AFFIRMATIVE** || **NEGATIVE** || **AFFIRMATIVE** || **NEGATIVE** ||
 * **NBHS 1** **won** || HNHS 1 || HNHS 1 || **NBHS 2 won** ||
 * **NBHS 2** **won** || HNHS 2 || **HNHS 2 won** || NBHS 3 ||
 * NBHS 3 || **WH 1** **won** || WH 1 || **NBHS 1** **won** ||

Pool B Hosted by SJC on Wed 25th June or Fri 27th June?? Round 3 **Prepared Debate...** Round 4 **Limited Prep moot was America's Cup challenge should be privately funded.**
 * **AFFIRMATIVE** || **NEGATIVE** || **AFFIRMATIVE** || **NEGATIVE** ||
 * SJC 1 **won** 260 || CHBC 1 245 || CHBC 1 280 || SJC 2 won 284 ||
 * SJC 2 **won** 287 || CHBC 2 271 || CHBC 2 won 242 || SJC 3 240 ||
 * SJC 3 254 || HBHS 1 **won** 257 || HBHS 1 237 || SJC 1 won 253 ||

Pool C hosted by NGHS Round 3 **Prepared Debate...** Round 4 **Limited Prep**
 * **AFFIRMATIVE** || **NEGATIVE** || **AFFIRMATIVE** || **NEGATIVE** ||
 * NGHS 1 || LC 1 || LC 1 || SHC 1 ||
 * NGHS 2 || LC 2 || LC 2 || NGHS 1 ||
 * SHC 1 || LC 3 || LC 3 || NGHS 2 ||

Pool D hosted KHS Round 3 **Prepared** **Debate**...Round 4 **Limited Prep**
 * **AFFIRMATIVE** || **NEGATIVE** || **AFFIRMATIVE** || **NEGATIV**E ||
 * **KHS 1 241 Won** || HGHS 1 239 || HGHS 1 236 || **KHS 2 243 Won** ||
 * KHS 2 273 || **HGHS 2 284 Won** || HGHS 2 257 || **KHS 3 306 Won** ||
 * **KHS 3 236 Won** || HGHS 3 184 || HGHS 3 233 || **KHS 1 271 Won** ||

Pool E-hosted by THS. Round 3 **Prepared Debate..**Round 4 **Limited Prep**
 * **AFFIRMATIVE** || **NEGATIVE** || **AFFIRMATIVE** || **NEGATIVE** ||
 * THS 1 || **IONA 1 won** || **IONA 1 won** || THS 2 ||
 * **THS 2 won** || IONA 2 || IONA 2 || **THS 1 won** ||

Term 3 Year 12/13 Round 5 Limited Preparation
 * AFFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE ||  ||
 * CHBC 1 || HNHS 1 ||  ||
 * CHBC 2 || HNHS 2 ||  ||


 * AFFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE ||
 * HGHS 1 || NBHS 1 ||
 * HGHS 2 || NBHS 2 ||
 * HGHS 3 || NBHS 3 ||


 * AFFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE ||
 * IONA 1 || WH1 ||
 * IONA 2 || HBHS 1 ||


 * AFFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE ||
 * KHS 1 || NGHS 1 ||
 * KHS 2 || NGHS 2 ||
 * KHS 3 || SHC 1 ||


 * AFFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE ||
 * LC 1 || SJC 1 ||
 * LC 2 || SJC 2 ||
 * LC 3 || SJC 3 ||


 * AFFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE ||
 * THS 1 || THS 2 ||






 * AFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE || AFFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE ||


 * AFFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE || AFFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE ||

Pool 3 Hosted by ....Limited Prep moot


 * AFFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE || AFFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE ||

__**Term 3**__ These debates are limited preparation debates.
 * Pool 4 Hosted by**
 * **Prepared Debate** |||| **Limited Prep Debate** ||
 * AFFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE || AFFIRMATIVE || NEGATIVE ||
 * **AFFIRMATIVE** || **NEGATIVE** || **Won** || **Moot** ||

THS - 303 v HGHS 2 – 250 win to THS CHBC 1 - 219 v LFC – 241 win to LFC HGHS 1 - 273 v CHBC 2 – 251 win to HGHS 1 NGHS 1 310 KHS 2 321 win to KHS 2 NGHS 2 259 HBHS 238 win to NGHS 2 KHS 1 262 SJC 242 win to KHS 1
 * __Term 1 2013 Results Year 11 __**
 * Round 1 – Prepared (MOOT: This house believes THAT schools are obsolete.)**

NBHS 1 - 262 v HNHS 241 win to NBHS 1 SHC – n/a v NBHS 2 – n/a win to NBHS 2 NBHS 3 - 198 v WFH - 219 win to Woodford

LFC - 247 v HGHS 1 – 316 win to HGHS 1 <span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif; font-size: 11pt;">THS - 266 v CHBC 2 – 288 win to CHBC 2 <span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif; font-size: 11pt;">HGHS 2 - 288 v CHBC 1 – 317 win to CHBC 1
 * Round 2 Limited Preparation (MOOT: This house believes THAT it is time for the Government to tax unhealthy food.)**

SJC 259 NGHS 1 271 win to NGHS 1 HBHS n/a KHS 2 n/a win to KHS 2 KHS 1 267 NGHS 2 243 win to KHS 1

NBHS 2 - 260 v NBHS 1 – 264 win to NBHS 1 HNHS – 261 v NBHS 3 – 234 win to HNHS WFH – 216 v SHC – 241 win to SHC


 * __Term 2 2013 Results – Year 11 Debating__**


 * __Round 3 Prepared: (MOOT: That New Zealand's Future Looks Bright)__**

HNHS vs NGHS 1 win to HNHS 238-233 HGHS 2 vs WFD win to HGHS 265-244 NGHS 2 vs HGHS 1 win to HGHS 253.5- 253

SJC vs THS win to SJC 257 – 244 HBHS vs NBHS1 win to NBHS1 281 – 247 NBHS2 vs LFC win to NBHS2 251 - 244

KHS2 v Iona – Won by KHS2 CHBC2 v KHS1 – Won by KHS1 CHBC1 v SHC – Won by CHBC1


 * __Round 4 Limited Prep: (MOOT: That synthetic highs should be criminalised)__**

NGHS 1 vs HGHS 2 win to NGHS 245-241 WFD vs NGHS 2 win to WFD 207.5-207 HGHS 1 vs HNHS win to HGHS 307- 292

LFC vs HBHS win to HBHS 211 – 210 NBHS1 vs SJC win to NBHS1 243 – 239 THS vs NBHS2 win to NBHS 223 – 195

CHBC1 v KHS2 – Won by KHS2 CHBC2 v Iona - Won by CHBC2 KHS1 v SHC – Won by KHS1


 * __<span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">Year 11 Debating Results Term 3 Rounds 5 and 6 __**

<span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">IONA vs HGHS 2 win to HGHS 2 297-294 <span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">KHS vs HNHS win to KHS 1 266 - 256 <span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">NGHS vs KHS 2 win to KHS 229 - 223 <span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">NGHS vs HGHS 1 win to HGHS 1 322 - 269
 * __<span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">Prepared Debate: __**<span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;"> //THAT citizens should be legally allowed to step in on behalf of the police if a situation calls for it”//

<span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">LFC 252 vs NBHS 251 - Winner: LFC <span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">NBHS 272 vs THS 262 - Winner: NBHS <span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">WFH 253 vs HBHS 271 - Winner: HBHS
 * __<span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">Limited prep: __**<span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;"> //THAT life was better before the internet.//

<span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">HGHS 2 vs NGHS 1 win to NGHS1 253 - 249 <span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">NGHS 2 vs IONA win to IONA 252 - 219 <span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">KHS 1 vs HGHS 1 win to HGHS 1 307 - 289 <span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">HNHS vs KHS 2 win to KHS 267 - 263.5

<span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">NBHS (2) 255 vs WFH 243 - Winner: NBHS (2) <span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">THS 242 vs THS 240 - Winner: THS <span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">HBHS 243 vs NBHS (1) 254 - Winner: NBHS (1)

<span style="font-family: Calibri,sans-serif;">Year 11 FINALS - (all with 6 wins each): HGHS 1, NBHS 1 and KHS.


 * __Year 11 Debating TERM 3 DRAW Rounds 5 and 6__**
 * HOST: Lindisfarne College**
 * DATE: Weds 11 September 2013**
 * Round 5 – Prepared**
 * **AFF** || **NEG** ||
 * LFC || NGHS 2 ||
 * NGHS 1 || THS ||
 * //default// || SJC ||
 * WFH || HBHS ||


 * Round 6 – Limited Preparation**
 * **AFF** || **NEG** ||
 * NGHS 2 || //default// ||
 * THS || LFC ||
 * SJC || WFH ||
 * HBHS || NGHS 1 ||

_


 * HOST: Hastings Girls’ High School**
 * DATE: Thurs 12 September 2013**
 * Round 5 – Prepared**
 * **AFF** || **NEG** ||
 * HGHS 1 || NBHS 2 ||
 * IONA || HGHS 2 ||
 * NBHS 1 || KHS 2 ||
 * KHS 1 || HNHS ||


 * Round 6 – Limited Preparation**
 * **AFF** || **NEG** ||
 * KHS 2 || HGHS 1 ||
 * NBHS 2 || IONA ||
 * IONA || NBHS 1 ||
 * HNHS || KHS 1 ||


 * Moot: THAT "Citizens should be legally allowed to step in on behalf of the police if a situation requires it." **
 * This is a CHANGE debate so teams will need to develop/address a model. **

To enter results, or follow discussion topics, click on the 'Discussion' tab above. For results, choose the discussion "format for posting results".

Notices. Term 1 =__General Information,__= =__ Moots, Dates and Senior Draws __=

**Results**
=Limited Preparation Rounds=